Today we’d like to introduce you to Paul Smith.
Hi Paul, thanks for sharing your story with us. To start, maybe you can tell our readers some of your backstory.
In 1998, I began the business selling CDs and Vinyl records online that were sourced from new ones purchased at discount prices. I got CDs from Circuit City on the day of release when they were often on sale. I’d also watch for 40% off coupons from Borders and would find expensive vinyl box sets,
In 2010, I opened my first physical location in Mechanicsburg, PA, After two moves because of unfavorable circumstances, I moved into the current location in town in 2011. It is a pre-civil war brick and mortar structure. Because I run another business (furniture restoration) I tapped one of my regular customers, who was retired, to cover most of the hours at the record store. He helped it to grow with a broad knowledge of music that filled in the gaps of my knowledge, including Classic Rock, Jazz, and Blues.
The following year, we began hosting live music on a small stage that had previously been used for an open mic when the location was a coffee shop. Over the years, our live music has grown to become a larger part of the picture with musicians performing all genres of music from acoustic to punk to sophisticated rock and jazz ensembles. Our footprint in small, but we make a large impression on the community, utilizing events as opportunities to promote our store. In addition to local musicians, we’ve pulled together shows including bands from New York, Philadelphia, Washington, and even a handful visiting from other countries.
With the increased exposure and larger customer base, we’ve expanded our specialty areas, and now have separate sections for Metal, R&B, and now one of the largest Blues sections in the region. In recent years, we’ve seen the resurgence of CDs too, so we’ve added more room in each department for those.
We do not have employees. Instead, each person brings their own music purchases for resale–much like a consignment arrangement at an antique mall. However, we have a growing inventory of New Releases and Reissues. Last year, we added another knowledgeable and resourceful person who has added a lot of deeper digs and rarities to add to our normal mix of mid-priced music that appeals to a larger base.
Can you talk to us a bit about the challenges and lessons you’ve learned along the way. Looking back would you say it’s been easy or smooth in retrospect?
The first couple of years had very low sales but also low expectations. It was more like a hobby. Gradually, we began to grow in volume, but that was deeply impacted by a national book and record chain called 2nd & Charles. We also saw big box stores expanding their vinyl record selections, which was not a problem at first, because the market was expanding as well. However, record companies began to cater to these stores, offering store-specific variations on new releases, which countered what had been a good effort from the Record Store Day organization to give indie record stores a unique edge. Also, big box stores (and larger record stores) began getting first dibs on new releases, leaving smaller stores without critical selections. In spite of that, we’ve had a loyal base of customers who know that they can get releases elsewhere (including Amazon) but choose to support local business.
Before we go, is there anything else you can share with us?
Over the years, downloads and steamed music has taken center stage, and CDs waned in sales for a time, but Vinyl never actually went away completely (much to the surprise of most people), and it began to grow exponentially in from 2010 onward, In the last couple of years, it surpassed all other forms of music in revenue and has become a genre favorite for all ages, ranging from teens to boomers.
Pricing:
- Budget $2 to $4
- Moderate $5 to $15
- Prime $20 to $50
- High Value, including Rarities $ 60 +++
- New Releases are priced at suggested list.
Contact Info:
- Website: https://www.RecordSmithOfPennsylvania.com
- Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/recordsmith5384/
- Facebook: https://facebook.com/recordsmithofpennsylvania





